Depends. Are you hoping to stay in the Navy for a full 20 or get out after your DIVO rides? If you want to do a full 20, then branching into the SWO Acquisitions Professional community is a great way to do that as you will open up a wide array of options for working on the acquisitions side of the IW world. The best way to do that is to get a technical masters at NPS and then work with the OCM and detailers after your first DH ride to go do acquisitions things at a warfare center or at a Fleet staff. If you're looking to get out then follow the advice below:
To maximize your chances of going civilian intel community, find a tour working at DIA, the Pentagon, a Fleet Staff, or a Joint Staff. This will expose you to multiple different Navy IW types as well as those in other services and agencies. This will provide the broadest network possible. I would also start looking into developing language skills and have those added to your service record. Your criminal justice degree just isn't the right degree for working in the intel community. You need either technical acumen (Read STEM degrees and experience working on particular systems) or specific knowledge of certain parts areas of the world and cultures.
A third option is to parlay your Navy experience into an agent position with NCIS. They have Cybersecurity, CounterIntel, and Anti-Terrorism divisions that would likely be right up your alley. If you end up in and ATFP job at any point in your SWO career, you will likely end up working with NCIS to some degree and will have contacts within the agency from there. Great way to get your foot in the door.