Ronin88
Well-Known Member
Unfortunately some of the worst info we have seen here and in recruiting comes from peoples commands because they go with what they believe, not what the board has selected and that has led many an applicant down a road of non-selection and delaying them getting a commission.
The board looks at degrees and GPA's first and foremost, NEC's are great for enlisted but they don't matter as an officer, they also don't care about how you did on advancement exams. I am not surprised you did that well given you GPA, you know how to study.
While the USN may have said your degree is technical that isn't what the boards define it by, unless it has calc and calc based physics it doesn't help, I had a Business Management major or something close to that get CW, but he had over a year of calc and physics in his background.
Your OAR is fine, your OAR doesn't get you selected.
I get you want to stay in your field, and that you would feel IP would be a another good option, but board statistics don't lie, those that have a non tech degree (no calc and physics) have either no selections for those designators or low selections, and a low selection when the overall selection rate is less than 10% isn't good.
I would also consider the fact that if you get a no you will need to redo your entire application, I would strongly encourage you to go for INTEL if you want to stay in IWC @RUFiO181 may have further insights from the most recent board.
Call my dumb but, I am still going to give CW a shot, I don't think I could forgive myself if I didn't at least try once. That being said I also don't have much choice my interviews for the IWC were all 1810's. Maybe I will get lucky, maybe I will have to re-apply. Correct me if I am wrong but, doesn't the board take experience into consideration as well? I also read some where on here that the reason priors don't always get selected is because they tend to to have lower test scores and GPA's, but my scores I am told are competitive.
That being said I really appreciate you taking the time and caring enough to reach out to me. You guys do a lot for this community and it is really appreciated. You may have convinced me to try for IP or SWO-IP instead of SWO-CW. I was looking at the statistics I found on the PERS-472 facebook page and they seem to be a little less competitive then SWO-CW