I have a tendency to defend Vance....
You make valid points. However, I say train Navy if given the choice... and I merely meant to warn the new poster about how much Vance is "Targetted and Sold" to the guys in the A-Pool. And now... it seems this thread has again degraded to a Vance-Bash-Session... mostly my fault. Sorry.
The leadership at Vance... varies. I may have bad experiences there... but of the three Navy guys I still keep in touch with from my time there... we all have between 4 and 7 pink sheets in our training jackets. And more than one of mine were for failing to complete a "Stand-Up" session... once because I misspoke a BoldFace. Not didn't know it... misspoke it. Once you've said it wrong, even if you immediatly correct your slip-up... you get Sat Down, are grounded from the flight schedule for the day, and get written up. Which when you transfer back to a Navy command they print out a pinksheet for you.
"Sir, I will maintain Aircraft Control, Analyze the Situation, Take the Proper Action, and Land as Soon as Conditions Permit"
etc etc... "Sir a Boldface applies: PCL - OFF, FIRE LEVER - PULL I mean FIRE HANDLE - PULL"
"ENS Purdue, SIT DOWN."
My other pinksheets are for getting airsick.