I most certainly did go through it, hence my right to pass judgment. When I showed up to VP-30, not only had my classmates who were umfo's already had P-3 exposure in several respects (NATOPS, sim, and plane exposure), but they also had started primary 20 something weeks behind me. Not to mention living in the air force dorms. Not to mention dealing with AF flight school. Not to mention the Navy liason office never had any idea what was going on (an AF 2nd LT was stashed there, enough said). I could go on. The entire time I was out there, not one navy guy I talked to there enjoyed any of his or her time there. Not knocking San Antonio, which could be fun to hang out in, but the AF training itself is seriously a step behind the navy. Having been trained in both environments, I'd take navy any day.
Randolph = 6 months long, very little applicable training value towards the P-3 world.
Umfo = 6 weeks long, ALL applicable training value towards P-3 world.
Umfo is such a hook up compared to Randolph, I am just glad that those behind me won't know any different.