If it didn't involve actual physical beating I am not sure you can really call it a 'beating', unless you want to sound like a tool.
"Beating" is a term used in the Navy and some other branches for getting put on your face. It isn't something said by tools who are exaggerating, it is just what it is called. Granted, those who dish out the beatings don't like the term because of what it implies to people who don't know what it really means.
MEMO TO ALL RDCs:
Stop breaking our candidates. If your candidates are suffering major injuries…you're doing it wrong.
It is actually probably the DIs more than the RDCs. As OCS goes on the chiefs become more chief-like and less RDC-like. The DIs don't change a lot until candio phase (if at all).
Some of the big injuries come from being out of shape, and some of them come from the candidates not wanting help. In week 1 if you go LLD you get rolled. Even if you don't miss a key event like wakeup wednesday. We lost a guy in my class during week 2 or 3 to an infection that he refused to get treatment for (he ultimately DORed and the whole thing was his fault, but he was rightfully worried that he'd miss too much PT and be rolled). And if you do have to go to the muscular/skeletal clinic (SMART) it takes basically all day. You miss classes, drill, and PT. I never worried too much about getting hurt at OCS. I worried though that I'd be rolled for something stupid like being LLD on the wrong day(s) if I did get hurt.
I don't really have any data to back this up, but I bet there would be fewer serious injuries if candidates felt like there would be fewer consequences for minor injuries.
Oh, and I bet the fact that they scrapped the terrible, terrible warm-up routines will help in the long run. If you wanted to stretch before a workout, you had to do it on your own damn time.