"Five years of recruiting experience" true. The ASTB is an indicator on one's potential as either a Student Pilot/NFO in flight school. If you score the bare minimums, like what your profile shows, it doesn't really help your cause demonstrating that you'll successfully complete Flight School. The Navy is investing a lot of $$$ and they want to make sure who they're taking can get through the pipeline.
You can throw as many LORs, volunteer experience, etc. etc. but in the end you need to demonstrate that you can complete flight school. The ASTB is the biggest indicator of that.