I don't think that one needs to max the PFT in order to show a bunch of 18-22 year olds why they're an Officer of Marines. Not everyone is capable of running an 18 minute three mile. My SPC at TBS was a rather large individual and said the best he could do was a 22 min 3 mile. Does that make him a bad officer? Hell no, because he looks out for his Marines and takes care of them. Yes, being physically fit is a plus, but the difference between a 225 and a 300 PFT score does not equate to being a bad officer. If a 225 wasn't good enough, it wouldn't be considered first class. In my opinion, as long as you are proficient in your job and take care of your Marines above everything else, then you are a good officer.