Nope, India can finance all that bs themself. Giving money to a poor country in Africa? Sure, sign me up. Giving it to a country that works against us for their own interests? Nope they can finance that themselves
Bro if you’re mad about people getting breaks or help when they could finance it all on their own, then I got some news for you that isn’t even off this continent.
Except time and again, this proves to be worthless. As soon as we want to wean a country off of US funding, they turn on us.
The business model where someone gives a customer a good deal so that they become loyal and tell all their friends about it is a uniquely American concept.
Like all the countries we help rebuild in Europe? They might turn on us, but it isn’t because of funding right meow.
There is a foreign policy concept where you help build infrastructure and industry in poor or vulnerable countries, and then you hit them over the back of the head and extort them. I think it’s called BRICS and is a big communism thing…but I’ve been seeing a similar technique in other places lately.
I understand your concern Spekkio, but I think you’re underestimating the power of supporting small nations and potential democracies. That said, there is a time to step away when it is clear we won’t be successful in the long run a la Middle East.
It’s nice to have a leader who actually stands up for America. Beautiful thing seeing Zelenskyy kicked out of the White House for disrespecting the very country that is responsible for Ukraine’s resistance. Hopefully he’ll get the hint and apologize or he better pray that Europe gets their act together. America’s back finally
Honestly dude, I was like 69% sure you were a Russian troll, but I’m about 96% sure your are in fact something else after this. Imagine telling a dude who’s been fighting an invading army he needs to show respect to a guy who has a track record of…*not supporting him.* I’d also like to point out, Ukraine downright stopped the Russians in their tracks despite being outgunned and out numbered with *minimal* aid at the outbreak of the war limited to defensive and light weaponry, most of which was from the UK and other European nations. The man was offered an extraction at the verge of peril and a government in exile but stayed and rallied and united his ENTIRE NATION to stop the Russian advance. I believe the quote was, “I don’t need an extraction, I need bullets” which is up there with JPJ quotes.
Further more, the entire continent, with the exception of Belarus, rallied behind him to a. Provide support b. Increase their own military capabilities. Europe has often been the champion of supporting Ukraine more than us, and has demonstrated their understanding of how Russia is a threat to their security.
Serious question, have you ever trained to fight with a NATO ally? Have you done it since this war kicked off?
A a matter of return on investment the money spent on the program in question could have been spent on other programs far and away more likely to develop favorable opinion of the US in India. This wasn't bags of rice arriving in a refugee camp with the caption " gift of the American people" printed on it. It is almost certain this funding was transparent to the Indian public. Also, consider Indian culture and society. Pretty sure funding trans programs is not on even radar of most Indians. Soft power is vitally important and That is why every dollar spent should deliver maximum return. Setting aside the actual subject of the program, funding it was a very poor investment. I think that is probably true of other USAID grants come to light. Ignore the outrage. Just consider how that money will influence the public or decision makers to benefit the USA.
Would you have supported giving the same amount of money for food aid or something directly labeled HIV/AIDS treatment/prevention?
It’s a fair point Wink. USAID is by no means a well run organization from what I have seen over the past 15ish years. It needs to be run better and find effective ways to promote that the US is the good guy in the world. My favorite classic example is the amount of grain we shipped to the Port of Djibouti in the 2008-2010 time frame to alleviate famine in Somalia. We literally unloaded shiploads of it only for it to rot in Djibouti because we didn’t have a way to get it into Somalia. Obviously poor execution.
That said, I don’t have a problem with helping a vulnerable group of people in the world when others won’t step up to help them on their own.