Clarity time...I do NOT think we are actually living in a "Big Brother" state and I fully support law enforcement in reigning in those people who rioted on January 6, 2021 or in any other riot that involves the destruction of property (private, state,or federal).
But, that said, there is no moral high ground here. History has a long, unflinching eye and it doesn't need too much hindsight to remember January 20, 2017 and the "J20" Movement. It was all over the press (I'll try to attach some video later). Their sole purpose, as clearly stated by the group, follows...
"The idea ... is we want to undermine Trump's presidency from the get-go. There has been a lot of talk of peaceful transition of power as being a core element in a democracy and we want to reject that entirely and really undermine the peaceful transition." (Jaffe, Sarah January 19, 2017,
"Interviews for Resistance: A Conversation with Legba Carrefour".
The Baffler)
Now, if I were the lady with the blindfold holding up the scales of JUSTICE and someone asked me..."Is there a difference between the 1/20/17and 1/6/21 actions?" "NO." is my undoubted answer. More than 200 people were arrested for 1/20/17 and I am pretty sure close to that number have been arrested for 1/6/21. But this is where it gets interesting...
In the pursuit of "justice" the DOJ issued a warrant to search the J20 group's website (more info...more arrests). This, of course, led to a legal challenge that went all the way to the Superior Court of D.C. where a judge decided that although a warrant could be issued (executed), "it does not have the right to rummage through the information contained on the [sic] website and discover the identity of, or access communications by, individuals not participating in alleged criminal activity,
particularly those persons who were engaging in protected First Amendment activities."
We have been where we are now before. In the end only 6 members of J20 went on trial and were found not guilty. Charges for the remaining 190 or so were dropped. I imagine the results for Jan 6, 2021 (with the critical exception of the murder of the officer) will be much the same. The government is going to level charges that are based on actions more than words but no one will face the charge of insurrection (just ask Cliven Bundy).
Some "saint" (Augustine, I believe) once said "Right is right even if no one is doing it. Wrong is wrong even if everyone is doing it." As I wrote at the beginning...there is no moral high ground here and my only/biggest fear is that the real losers will be ordinary American citizens who may lose fundamental rights for the sake of an Orwellian "peace."