Spekkio
He bowls overhand.
I really could care less whether or not one is a "true conservative" (whatever that means). What got me not liking Romney is your second point: Romney just seems like the stereotypical politician who will say anything to get elected, even if he doesn't believe it himself.I never cared he was Mormon (more beer for me), but the 2 big things:
1-Governor of Mass. If you win there, you are not really conservative. Conservative by local standards, yes. His Universal Health Care that made it illegal to NOT HAVE health insurance in MA, put my dad's company out of business. A business that he spent 30+ years building.
2-He seem to say what people want to here, and he comes off as a flip/flopper and insincere. Like when he told people that he would "take care of Michigan". Mac told them the auto jobs are not coming back. I agree with Mac on that. Auto industry in MI is going the way of the dodo. Find new, more stable industries.
Whether you like McCain's stance on the issues or not, he's as much of a straight-shooter as you're going to get (aside from Ron Paul, but since we're talking about electability here...).
On the Democratic side, Hillary is the analogue of Romney, and Obama stands for "change" (whatever that means).