Is the author who I think it is? Maybe that was what he was doing in his office 19 hours a day. I thought he was an IA in Iraq. Or are they talking about the H-bear? I didn't know him real well. But-- its not true. From the unit he was attached to, the scholarship awarding still seems to break down pretty much blind to major selection. It is sort of a tradeoff-- soft majors are a little behind the power curve in some things at the fleet, but their collegiate attrition is a good bit lower, and they are often better at more important things, like writing evaluations or recommendations. If I was an enlisted dude who had to work under someone, I would rather work under a technically clueless guy that could write my recommendation is flawless rhyme royal than some tech-hotshot that didn't understand the little characters formed sounds...
Also-- do any current mids remember taking that survey about 2 years ago on technical majors vs. nontechnical? It put forward pretty much everything which has been discussed here as a possible option.
PS- Shocked? You have talked to the 'prospective midshipman' right? Personality is still at least somewhat grade-able, I think...