A lot of guys take the Fallon SAR job as a "it's this or non-flying shore duty". Given that, I'd probably make it work.
All in all, I'd rank jobs as follows (in broad strokes):
There's some variation for OCONUS/CONUS and what's career enhancing, but that's the general hierarchy.
- Flying
- Good Deal Shore Duty
- Staff Duty
- Ships Company or similar Sea Duty
- Active Warzone/IA
Generally agree with some exceptions on some of the IA's I've seen that appear, at least on a surface level, to be good(ish) deals.