• Please take a moment and update your account profile. If you have an updated account profile with basic information on why you are on Air Warriors it will help other people respond to your posts. How do you update your profile you ask?

    Go here:

    Edit Account Details and Profile

War in Israel

Status
Not open for further replies.

Random8145

Registered User
Contributor
of heavy machinery?
That's that not what a machinist does. A machinist makes parts from prints. In the old days, machinists operated manual lathes and mills, today though it is much more CNC (computer numerical control) machines which often combine both. Almost all mechanical parts are made by machinists. Even a part that is produced by the millions, it was machinists that likely aided in the setting up and programming of the machines to produce them. Machinists make the molds that plastic injection molding machines use to make all the huge variety of plastic parts as well.
 
Last edited:

FLGUY

“Technique only”
pilot
Contributor
To bring it back to the topic at hand.. Can someone who understands war better than me explain to me the “legality” of gaining land as a result of war? Are those “spoils” taken or given? If given, then wouldn’t that undermine the claim that Israel illegally occupies Palestinian land? Or is that more so a claim regarding Israel’s initial founding in the 40’s? I want to better understand the realities of “military occupation” and land disputes a bit better in this context.
 

Griz882

Frightening children with the Griz-O-Copter!
pilot
Contributor
To bring it back to the topic at hand.. Can someone who understands war better than me explain to me the “legality” of gaining land as a result of war? Are those “spoils” taken or given? If given, then wouldn’t that undermine the claim that Israel illegally occupies Palestinian land? Or is that more so a claim regarding Israel’s initial founding in the 40’s? I want to better understand the realities of “military occupation” and land disputes a bit better in this context.
Land seized during conflict can legally be used for treaty negotiations. After the Mexican-American War the U.S. gained significant territory from Mexico in the treaty process but didn’t take the whole of the territory that was occupied. The same applies to the Spanish-American War. In both cases, neither action was contrary to international convention. In the past Israel got significant real estate gains after her wars and often in exchange for land occupied during conflict such as the Suez. In the case of this war I’m guessing that Israel is looking for a few hundred years of land to create a deeper buffer zone between Gaza and Israel - but in any case a treaty (more likely a “cease fire” in this case) will be brokered by international concerns.
 

taxi1

Well-Known Member
pilot
Does anyone have a good book recommendation on the history of the geography and region. Not looking to go back as far as Jesus, but genuinely wanting to understand the area more broadly. Thanks . . . .
A bunch of years ago, I read a book about the history of the Middle Ages. After reading it, I realized that I really didn't understand what was going on in the Balkans until I'd read the book. The threads run that deep over there.

My mom just bought this one for me. Will report results.

1698675229386.png
 

Tumbleweed33

Well-Known Member
A bunch of years ago, I read a book about the history of the Middle Ages. After reading it, I realized that I really didn't understand what was going on in the Balkans until I'd read the book. The threads run that deep over there.
Is there any chance you remember the name of that book?
 

MIDNJAC

is clara ship
pilot
That's that not what a machinist does. A machinist makes parts from prints. In the old days, machinists operated manual lathes and mills, today though it is much more CNC (computer numerical control) machines which often combine both. Almost all mechanical parts are made by machinists. Even a part that is produced by the millions, it was machinists that likely aided in the setting up and programming of the machines to produce them. Machinists make the molds that plastic injection molding machines use to make all the huge variety of plastic parts as well.

So you don't make heavy machinery?
 

IRfly

Registered User
None
To bring it back to the topic at hand.. Can someone who understands war better than me explain to me the “legality” of gaining land as a result of war? Are those “spoils” taken or given? If given, then wouldn’t that undermine the claim that Israel illegally occupies Palestinian land? Or is that more so a claim regarding Israel’s initial founding in the 40’s? I want to better understand the realities of “military occupation” and land disputes a bit better in this context.

Check out UN Security Council Resolution 242, which is one of the keystones of this (very modern) history.
Security Council resolution, so it is considered to be binding international law. Preamble emphasizes the inadmissibility of territory gained in war, which is declared illegal in the UN Charter (and which we, the US, are upholding as a reason that Russia can't annex Ukraine).
UNSCR 242 demands (in English) that Israel withdraw "from territories" gained in the recent conflict (the 1967 war, in which Israel gained military control of Gaza from Egypt, the West Bank from Jordan, and the Golan Heights from Syria), while I believe in French it says "from the territories" gained, which has been a point of contention among scholars, diplomats, and other people to whom words matter.

Fun fact for all you history buffs, btw: Egypt and Syria were, at the time, a single state called the United Arab Republic. So Israel seized Gaza and Golan from the UAR, which broke back up into Egypt and Syria in 1971-ish.

The point, though, was not to force a unilateral Israeli withdrawal, but to push towards a negotiated settlement.

Keep in mind, though, that the question at this point was "negotiated between whom?" Jordan and Israel? UAR/Egypt/Syria and Israel? Between Israel and the people living in the West Bank and Gaza, many of whom were refugees, and all of whom had been residents of another country up until that point?

The PLO, by the way, was a thing at the time--a creation of UAR (Egyptian) intelligence, based in Cairo. No skin in the game or boots on the ground. Long story, like many of these stories.

To me, this is one of the cores of this problem: who leads the Palestinians, speaks for the Palestinians, can make and enforce agreements for the Palestinians? The UN kind of chose the PLO to be the figurehead organization, but they never really had the legitimacy to make the deals. More recently, Hamas was elected in Gaza, but as soon as they were elected they ensured that they would never be un-elected, so they're basically a mafia/terrorist organization, curiously supported by both Iran and Netanyahu (until recently).

There's a lot more to be said about the issue of territory, but this post is too long already .
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top