Actually 2 dudes got screwed by VT-86! :icon_rage And both were/are good sticks and instructors! Let me clarify however, one was a P-3 dude and the other E-2! Also from everything I have heard Osbourne is a tool! He need not be in the same catagory as the others. The others also had well over 1000 hours in the Buckeye and were well qualified (One was even the OCF Stan)!
As someone who has been on two sides of the fence in Naval Avation, EP-3's and Prowlers, and going through both training tracks I have to disagree with you about the guys getting screwed over. When I went through VT-86 everyone going through T-2's had twelve flights. The first three were basically FAM'ss and you usually did a cross country for them, the next three were combined Form/low-level/bombing pattern flights. the last six were called ATM's, another name for basic ACM.
When I went through VT-86 all of the T-2 instructors had flown TACAIR and we had no E-2/C-2 or P-3 guys. Because over half the stuff, 75% if you want to be technical, was stuff that TACAIR guys did I see no reason why someone who does not have the background in what they are teaching should be there. I don't care if the guy has 1500 hours in type, how much experince does he have doing what he would be teaching?
One other big thing to consider, the group of T-2 instructors in VT-86 is tiny compared to the number at Meridian or Kingsville. I remember counting th number of T-2's on the ramp in Pensacola and came up with 9. One or two instructors who are behind the power curve from the rest of them would have a disproportionate impact compared to K'ville or Meridian. You can't just stick a guy with flying RI's or ANAV's in VT-86, they have to know how to the TACAIR stuff from the start. This is nothing against P-3 or E-2/C-2 guys, they jsut don't have the background.
Finally, Shane wasn't exactly a tool, he just had a big head that was inflated several times larger than it was originally when he became a 'hero'.