I’ve read that around here somewhere too and it definitely sounds like smoke is being blown lol. I’ve seen people get picked up with PFAR of 6 and others were declined with PFAR of 8. Who knows honestly. Let’s just hope this board is generous ?
It likely has to do with waivers, that is what happens most of the time, there have been several instances where I have been PM'd by a person who was denied with a high PFAR asking if I thought their waiver could be overcome.
NRC gave out stats several years ago and I don't remember the exact percentages and this was before they switched to a min of 6 which they have now switched back, however it was 9 or 8 was rare to not select (they didn't exclude waiver issues), 7 was 50/50 shot, 6 was a bit less than 50/50 and 5 was rarely selected. This is why when they switched from 5 to 6 min it really didn't chance much.