• Please take a moment and update your account profile. If you have an updated account profile with basic information on why you are on Air Warriors it will help other people respond to your posts. How do you update your profile you ask?

    Go here:

    Edit Account Details and Profile

Chinese Intelligence Ship Harasses USNS Impeccable

Status
Not open for further replies.

Flash

SEVAL/ECMO
None
Super Moderator
Contributor
We're gonna "protest" ... now that should settle their little ChiCom hash.

I would hate to point out the obvious but what else can we really do?

Maybe it's just my hawkish nature but why on earth did those vessels not get blasted to hell? That's too close for comfort in my humble opinion.

It is a USNS ship and civilian manned, it has no major weapon systems.
 

A4sForever

BTDT OLD GUY
pilot
Contributor
I would hate to point out the obvious but what else can we really do?
Nothing in this world is "obvious" ... if the ChiComs violate the rules of the road and a collision occurs, that's too damn bad & we are not at "fault" ... but if you're hung up on "obvious" -- try this: this would NOT have happened were the Bushie's still at the helm ... :)
 

Mumbles

Registered User
pilot
Contributor
I had a salty AWC Jez type tell me about the Russians trying to retrieve "his" DICASS buoys in the med in the late 80's..... the crew waited until Ivan had the active buoy on the deck of the trawler before Chief hit the PING button....I don't know how many watts of noise that thing puts out, but he said all the Russians were blown overboard. By the time that P-3 landed at Sig, 6th Fleet was already waiting for them. They got the perfunctory ass chewing, but when it was over, the Admiral said that it was one of the funniest things he had ever seen.
 

FLYTPAY

Pro-Rec Fighter Pilot
pilot
None
Maybe it's just my hawkish nature but why on earth did those vessels not get blasted to hell? That's too close for comfort in my humble opinion.
Yeah try that with a ship that has some firepower and see who is sinking then.
 

KCOTT

remember to pillage before you burn
pilot
Poorly written, but I think it meant to say that after the US drenched their crew, they stripped out of their wet clothes and continued what they were doing. That's the way I read it.
Oh, was wondering if it was some sort of Chinese SWO tactic, lol.
 

snake020

Contributor
I would hate to point out the obvious but what else can we really do?

Move a carrier battle group or two 12 miles off the Chinese coast and park it there for a couple of weeks. That's what I would like to see.
 

FLYTPAY

Pro-Rec Fighter Pilot
pilot
None
Move a carrier battle group or two 12 miles off the Chinese coast and park it there for a couple of weeks. That's what I would like to see.
Young Padowan......not a very wise move if you like not getting shot down or sunk.
 

Flash

SEVAL/ECMO
None
Super Moderator
Contributor
Nothing in this world is "obvious" ... if the ChiComs violate the rules of the road and a collision occurs, that's too damn bad & we are not at "fault" ... but if you're hung up on "obvious" -- try this: this would NOT have happened were the Bushie's still at the helm ... :)

Yes, then you put one of our survey ships out of action for who knows how long?

As for your later assertion, how do you know that it did not happen when either one of them was at the helm? And if it did, what would they have done differently? Send a letter asking for plane....opps, I meant ship, back? And pay $34,000 too?

'Letter of the Two Sorries'

Payment to PRC
 

A4sForever

BTDT OLD GUY
pilot
Contributor
Yes, then you put one of our survey ships out of action for who knows how long?
YOUR alternative is to let "them" think they can do this w/ impunity ... ??? Sorry, I think not; as that's what preceded the PUEBLO fiasco ... and many others.

As far as the "Bushie's" comment -- YOU KNOW EXACTLY WHAT I'M REFERRING TO -- THE OBAMA ADMIN IS BEING TESTED ON MANY FRONTS AND THIS IS JUST ONE OF THE MANY. To date, I'm not impressed. You don't REALLY want to get into the disgraceful EP-3 thing again, do you ... ???

Flash ... you'll just never "get it". You're NOT a "fighter" ... probably never have been; you're just not wired that way. :)


 

Flash

SEVAL/ECMO
None
Super Moderator
Contributor
YOUR alternative is to let "them" think they can do this w/ impunity ... ??? Sorry, I think not; as that's what preceded the PUEBLO fiasco ... and many others.

Yet you still give no alternatives, because they are few and far between. That is the reality, you seem to be ever further removed from it for some strange reason. :eek:

You don't REALLY want to get into the disgraceful EP-3 thing again, do you ... ???

I am not the only one who disagrees with you here on this board about that, you can't always assume you know the whole story and what you think is always right.

Flash ... you'll just never "get it". You're NOT a "fighter" ... probably never have been; you're just not wired that way. :)

You really think you can judge someone from what they say/post over the internet? Pretty bold, probably mistaken........and very sad. :(
 

A4sForever

BTDT OLD GUY
pilot
Contributor
Yet you still give no alternatives, because they are few and far between. That is the reality, you seem to be ever further removed from it for some strange reason. :eek:
The alternatives are patently obvious -- or should be: armed air/sea escort(s) OR run 'em down if they violate the ROR ... it happens. It's happened. It shows you mean business ... your obfuscation & equivocation show YOU don't ...
I am not the only one who disagrees with you here on this board about that, you can't always assume you know the whole story and what you think is always right.
I am not the only one who disagrees w/ you here, either .... you just gotta take a stand on SOMETHING .... etc., etc. ... :sleep_125
You really think you can judge someone from what they say/post over the internet? Pretty bold, probably mistaken........and very sad. :(
I gotta "judge" on SOMETHING after all these years of verbal sparring ... what you bring to the discussion does NOT encourage me ... but I'll agree on one thing ... "very sad", as you say .... :(

:sleep_125:sleep_125:sleep_125:sleep_125:sleep_125:sleep_125:sleep_125:sleep_125:sleep_125:sleep_125:sleep_125
 

Mumbles

Registered User
pilot
Contributor
As much as I've clashed w/ the Flasher in the past....
while he is not nearly the red meat, visceral Cretin Phillistine right winger that I am, ( and I know that I'm in proud company on this board...Squeeze, Herc, and Squorch notwithstanding)....The Flasher is a proud 'Merican despite his Canuck, (hotty) wifey. He'd take a bullet for old Glory as soon as anyone else one this forum. Those idiot Chinamen weren't even sanctioned by the PLAN Navy... at least to some of us folks in the IC...they just demonstrated a lot of buffoonery.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top