SaltyDawg85
Active Member
I am under the assumption that cutting/gaining fat and muscle is strictly a matter of mathematics—reaching a calorie deficit/surplus. My understanding is that the macros can control the quality of your loss or gain, but not whether it happens. If you have crap macros but you still have a 500-calorie deficit, you're going to lose weight. You just might lose more muscle than you'd like. Likewise, if you eat crap macros and a surplus of calories, you are going to gain...but you might gain more fat than you want to. Again, this is my understanding of it. I'm actually operating on these principles myself right now, so the conversation is useful to me.
On that note, I'd figure eating macro-valuable foods (i.e., quality complex carbs, lean protein sources) would help you maintain the right calorie and macro balance to achieve optimal gain/loss (depending on your goals). Am I correct, or completely out of whack on this?
EDIT: Also, the above statement assumes the calorie/surplus deficit is affected by both exercise and diet, however you choose to achieve it.
To avoid losing muscle you have to make sure your macros include enough protein, since that's what rebuilds muscles broken down through exercise. But at it's simplest - yes, losing weight is a simple mathematical equation - calories out versus calories in. You could theoretically eat nothing but twinkies and as long as you finished with a calorie deficit you'd lose weight.... but you'd probably be in awfully poor shape.
It sounds like you've got the right idea though.
http://www.swole.me is a useful utility for developing a diet tailored to your goals . Also, if you're going to count calories, the myfitnesspal app for android or iPhone is also excellent, and free. And while I'm plugging resources, I find that http://www.bodybuilding.com has a wealth of great information concerning nutrition and exercise. Don't let the name fool you, there is a TON of useful info on there for folks looking to trim down as much as there is for folks trying to bulk up.