The Hamilton is a dressier watch, but truthfully at $600 you get what you pay for. The lume is extremely underwhelming...
I agree. I don't look at my Hamilton as a tool, it's a piece of jewelry. Even my Skyhawk, with all of it's aviation tools, is basically an accessory. In fact, the same can be said for all of my analog watches.
If I was going to wear one of them in the cockpit though, especially at night, there's no contest. I'd grab the Luminox. That's literally what their entire line is built for - those glass tubes are guaranteed to glow for 25 years. Sure, the watch is made of (very durable) plastic, but it's still a Swiss watch with a Sapphire crystal, great water-resistance rating, super easy to read - day or night - and it's probably the most comfortable watch I own. Honestly, I bought it as a novelty just because I always wanted a Luminox and never really expected to wear it, but it's become my daily wear if I don't want something fancier. As an added bonus, I picked it up for less than $150.

